Many people who consider themselves non-believers are hesitant to use the term atheist to describe themselves. That is the case with Ian Jack,the man who wrote the article I linked to below. He was in the hospital and when asked his religion he chose to say none rather than call himself an atheist. I usually tend to get two explanations when I question people why they think this way. The first reason is that it carries what many would consider a bad stigma with it. I believe that to overcome this stigma we must be more open about calling ourselves atheists. When people begin to realize that people they know and like are atheists, they may start to think differently about atheists in general.
The other reason, which Jack touches on in his article, is that people don't want to be defined by by just one term. Particularly a term that describes a negative about themselves. By negative I don't mean a trait that is bad but by something they don't do or believe. However, I think that there are other terms that identify us by our negatives that we use. Nobody is offended by being called a non-smoker for example.
Also, we often identify ourselves by only one term at a time, perhaps as a runner or a teacher. So those that say they don't want to be labeled by just one term should realize that we do this already. It usually is just a matter of context, obviously if someone asks you what you do, you wouldn't say atheist just as you wouldn't answer runner to that question. We have many labels which we use to describe ourselves and we just pick the appropriate one for the situation.
Christians label themselves with a single term and our term which is actually much broader should be suitable for us. Labeling yourself a christian comes with assumptions also, both positive and negative. So be proud of being an atheist and when asked about your religion, use that as a proper time to label yourself and be honest. "I am an atheist."
http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2011/dec/23/ian-jack-not-an-atheist?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+theguardian%2Fcommentisfree%2Frss+%28Comment+is+free%29
I think, like the Bill Maher video you posted, it can be considered wrong to say "atheist" when asked what your religion is because atheism is not a religion. The answer "none" doesn't necessarily imply shame, but perhaps just a difference of opinions on what the definition is.
ReplyDeleteOf course, I do agree with the overall point. The atheist community has no chance at changing the negative view the majority holds without more atheists admitting whay they are and showong that they live good, caring lives.
Thanks for your comment, I agree it can be not quite a "correct" answer to say atheist when asked your religion, I don't intend for it to come across as a religion but an answer that lets them know you don't have a religion. More importantly in Ian Jack's case when he said none and she asked if he was an atheist he was hesitant to say yes. My hope is that we can get to the point where we don't have that hesitation anymore. Obviously there are some people who would be putting their jobs at risk and I think that it has to be a judgement call for each person and situation. I encourage people to start being open when the only risk is the person's negative judgment. After being more open about it myself I have been fortunate to not only not have a negative backlash, but have found out that I work with two other atheists.
ReplyDelete